Vanilla Ice had this exactly right when he said, using the conditional, “If you’ve got a problem, yo, I’ll solve it.”
He said “if.”
Most people you would like to sell to have a symptom, not a problem. They can’t name what’s wrong – which means, yo, you can’t solve it.
That’s a problem for your business.
The distinction between “root problem” and “symptom” is one many marketing frameworks miss. But skip it, and you can end up talking over your buyer’s head.
This is especially true if your company does something different, innovative or non-obvious.
You know – something valuable.
In this essay:
The difference between your buyer’s problem and their symptoms.
How that difference tells you what you really offer.
An exercise, complete with AI prompt, for you to do right now that tests how your business stands up against others in your field.
Let’s start with everyone’s favorite framework.
STORYBRAND IS FAILING YOU
I love StoryBrand, I do.
At this point I know that’s a bit like saying I love Crocs or Friends or Pumpkin Spice Lattes. It’s not very punk rock.
StoryBrand became the world’s most tried small-business messaging approach (probably? I haven’t done the math) by doing just what it teaches you to do: Keep the message simple. Keep it clear. Know who your client is, what problem they have, and how you help them solve it.
And make them the hero.
Most of which is great. But there’s a big assumption buried in that person/problem/plan approach that won’t sit right if your org’s a bit bigger or the work you do’s a bit more complicated:
Storybrand assumes your buyer knows what problem they have.
They often don’t. Take B2B: a client might say “our network’s slow” or “we’re not closing sales” or “we’re stressed out about AI” – but those are symptoms. If you sell that client a bigger data pipe or offer closing scripts or lead a stress retreat, you might be solving the wrong problems. You might just be treating symptoms without offering a cure.
Which earns a paycheck but doesn’t have an impact.
That won’t work for long.
If you want to change something in your industry, to do things different – then you’re not just selling a solution people know they need. You’re selling the problem first.
You have to convince clients something’s wrong that they don’t know is wrong.
Which means you’re not marketing to Mario, but to Link.
LINK’S LOST
Here’s the first screen in Super Mario Brothers, which us ‘80s kids all know by heart.
Where’s Mario going?
To the right, of course. The screen scrolls that way only, so one second of experimentation teaches the new player that their goal is just to walk and walk. Eventually, there’s a flag.
Mario is rescuing a princess – though the player may not know that yet.
But they know what to do. They walk.
Their problem, then, is anything that stops that progress: turtles, pits, tall pipes. If Mario is your market, then your message can be “we’ll help you jump that big pit.”
But Link is different.
Here’s the first screen from the Legend of Zelda, made by the same team at the same video game company a few months after Mario. Link’s the hero in the middle.
Where’s Link going?
God knows.
And the player doesn’t – you’ve got three paths and a cave. Anything could get you there, because you don’t yet know where “there” is.
Link is also rescuing a princess – but good luck selling him solutions for that, because he doesn’t know his problem yet. Should he fight fiends? Burn trees? Leap pits?
He doesn’t know.
He still has feelings, though. Link’s probably lost, confused – and when he touches monsters on the very next screens, ouch, he feels pain.
It’s dangerous to go alone.
Above I wrote about the difference between skipping straignt to treatments and diagnosing problems first. If your client’s Mario, you sell treatments – you can be the drug, because they know their illness.
If they’re Link, you have to be the doctor first.
YOUR DIAGNOSIS IS YOUR DIFFERENCE
When you talk to clients, don’t start with their problem. Start with pain.
Staring with problems works when you agree on what the problem is: Mario has pits to cross. Athletes need shoes. A toilet needs unplugging.
Companies solving problems everyone understands compete with other companies also doing that – so products make the difference. You make better bridges, better shoes or better plumbers. If you can’t make better, you sell cheaper.
But I bet this isn’t you.
For innovators, new perspective is what makes you special. You don’t think the problem is what others think; you solve for something else.
Define the problem better and you get to be the only company with the right solution.
Don’t define it – and you’re pitching something no one knows they need.
To do it right, you start with what your client always knows: their pain. A doctor asks you where it hurts and lists the symptoms; then they diagnose. The diagnosis is the skill – but pain brings patients through the door.
StoryBrand conflates these, but you might not have the luxury.
ASK COMPETITORS HOW YOU’RE DIFFERENT
This week I’ve been in a deep dive with a new client. We’re positioning an offer in the context of their market and the change they want to make.
This sort of work is always a collaboration. I start out with interviews, then strategy sessions. Soon we’re texting random ideas at all hours; it’s fantastic.
One session ended with this question: What do we solve for that’s different from what our competitors solve for?
The next day, this CEO sent me a bunch of screenshots: ads he’d seen on LinkedIn from companies that seemed like competition.
Here’s what I did with those ads, so you can do it too.
I made a table:
Symptom Diagnosis Cure
I looked at each ad and filled in the columns:
What symptom is this company saying buyers have?
What problem do they say is causing it?
What cure do they prescribe?
Do this for five companies who address the same symptom you do. You might discover your problem’s different.
Do you believe different things from your competitors about where client pain comes from?
This makes you very interesting.
And you can use it.
Just don’t start with it. You always start what they feel.
A PROMPT THAT MAKES THE HARD PART EASY
Scouring the web for your competitors’ ads is the slow part of the exercise above – so here’s an AI prompt that does it for you.
Copy this prompt into your favorite LLM. Edit the top line, the part in brackets, so it’s a plan-talk description of the pain your clients feel.
Then hit enter; your AI should do the rest.
To work, your LLM needs to be able to use a browser to find ads – which probably means you’ll need the paid version of most AIs. (Sorry.)
Assuming you have that, your LLM will search the most likely social media platform for 5 ads that address that pain, show you screenshots and give you the ads’ text for you to analyze.
The prompt will do the analysis too, telling you what your AI thinks each ad is naming as the problem and how your competitor plans to fix it. You can scroll to the grid at the bottom of the AI response to see this part – but I recommend looking at the ads and trying to analyze them yourself first.
Because your expertise, not ChatGPT’s, is your competitive advantage.
I’m going to keep tweaking this and make it another tool I use when working with future clients.
If you try it, let me know what you learn about yourself.